The best Italian restaurant for groups in Greenwich Village is the one that makes the organizer’s job easy: a menu built for sharing, clear rules for big bookings, and a kitchen that can feed twelve people at once without the pasta going cold. Those are the tests we’d use, and this guide shows how Da Andrea Greenwich Village, at 35 West 13th Street between 5th and 6th Avenues, measures up against each one. Our firm advice for any table over eight is to order family style and agree the shared plates before you sit down.
Most pages ranking for this search are roundups that never tell the person holding the reservation how many pastas to order for ten, or what to do when the group grows from 14 to 27.
That person is who this is for: the parent hosting family during NYU Family Weekend, the friend planning a birthday for eleven, the manager booking a Union Square office team.
Key Takeaways
- Judge a group restaurant on sharing food, booking rules and how the room handles a long table, not on how many “best of” lists it appears in.
- At Da Andrea Greenwich Village, parties of up to 25 hold the booking with a credit card; groups of 26 to 30 pay a 25% non-refundable deposit.
- There’s no private or semi-private room, so groups dine in the main room. Plan for a lively table, not speeches.
- For eight or more, order family style: roughly one pasta for every three or four guests, plus antipasti and a few secondi for the table.
What Makes the Best Italian Restaurant for Groups in Greenwich Village?
A restaurant earns that title when it feeds everyone at the same pace, gives the host clear booking terms, and serves food that works passed around a table. A beautiful room won’t save a dinner where half the table waits forty minutes for mains.
Italian food has a head start, since antipasti, primi and secondi assume shared plates. Here’s how we’d score any candidate, and how Da Andrea Greenwich Village handles each point.
| What to look for | Why it matters for a group | How Da Andrea Greenwich Village handles it |
|---|---|---|
| Dishes that share well | Family-style ordering keeps the bill and the pacing under control | Tigelle, burrata, veal meatballs and handmade pastas all split cleanly across a table |
| Clear large-party rules | The host needs to know what’s required before inviting anyone | Credit card to hold up to 25 guests; 25% non-refundable deposit for 26 to 30 |
| Honest about space | Surprises on the night are worse than limits you knew about | No private dining space; groups sit in the main room |
| Easy to reach | Guests arrive from different neighborhoods | West 13th Street, a short walk from Union Square and Washington Square Park |
| Options for mixed diets | One vegetarian shouldn’t be stuck with a side salad | Several vegetarian pastas and vegetable dishes on the dinner menu |
| A set-menu route for bigger events | Removes ordering decisions for 20+ people | An Event Brochure with event prix-fixe menus for brunch, lunch and dinner |
Fame does nothing for the host trying to feed 14 people at once.
How Group Size Changes Your Plan
The right approach shifts at roughly every size bracket, and the biggest jump comes at 26 guests, when a deposit replaces the card hold. Know which bracket you’re in before you send the invite.
| Group size | How to book | How to order | What to watch |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2–6 | Regular OpenTable booking | À la carte works; share two or three antipasti | Weekend nights in an intimate room fill early |
| 7–12 | Book well ahead; note the occasion | Family style, chosen by the host or one deputy | A long table means people at the ends can’t hear each other, so seat talkers in the middle |
| 13–25 | Large-group booking held with a credit card | Family style or an Event Brochure prix-fixe | Get a firm headcount a few days out; late extras are hard to seat |
| 26–30 | Large-group booking with a 25% non-refundable deposit | Event Brochure menus make most sense here | Only commit the deposit once numbers are solid |
| Over 30 | Not covered by the posted policy | Ask the restaurant directly | Don’t assume it’s possible; contact the team before inviting anyone |
The 7–12 bracket is where most hosts go wrong. It feels small enough for everyone to order alone, and then twelve separate dishes arrive at slightly different times.
For the larger brackets, use the large group events page, which has the booking form and the Event Brochure.
The Family-Style Ordering Plan for a Group Dinner in Greenwich Village
Family style means the table orders a spread of dishes and everyone helps themselves, and for eight or more it’s the method we’d insist on. It keeps the courses together and stops one guest’s expensive order from turning the bill-split into an argument.
Our rule of thumb is one pasta for every three or four guests. That’s our own guidance, not a kitchen rule, and a hungry crowd of college students can push it closer to one per three.
Antipasti work on a similar ratio. Order the tigelle first regardless of size, since warm Modenese flatbread buns with Parma prosciutto are built for passing, and a New York Times column once singled them out.
| Guests | Antipasti | Pastas | Secondi | Contorni | Desserts |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8 | Tigelle plus 2 more | 2–3 | 2, split | 2 | 2–3 to share |
| 10 | Tigelle plus 3 more | 3 | 2–3, split | 2 | 3 |
| 12 | 2 orders of tigelle plus 3 | 3–4 | 3 | 3 | 3–4 |
| 16 | 2 orders of tigelle plus 4 | 4–5 | 4 | 4 | 4–5 |
| 20+ | Consider an Event Brochure prix-fixe instead |
Treat these as starting points. Secondi are the course most groups over-order.
Which Dishes Pass Well Around a Table
Handmade pasta is the reason to bring a group to a Northern Italian kitchen, because fresh egg pasta holds its sauce when served onto a dozen plates.
From the antipasti, pick for contrast. The Burrata con Basilico and the Polpettine di Vitello (veal meatballs with ricotta) are easy crowd-pleasers. The Calamaretti alla Griglia, grilled squid with a corn and cucumber salad, appears only on the Greenwich Village menu, so it’s the plate that makes a Village dinner different from one in Chelsea. Add Verdure Grigliate con Caprino for the vegetable lovers.
For pasta, cover three bases: a meat ragù (Spaghetti Bolognese or the Pappardelle with sweet sausage ragout), something rich (Cappellacci Tartufo e Porcini or Gnocchetti di Patate), and something from the sea (Ravioli di Crostacei or Tagliolini Neri alle Vongole). If there’s a vegetarian at the table, make one of the pastas the Pennette con Melanzane or the Fettuccine alla Mediterranea.
Secondi should be dishes that slice or spoon easily. Galletto Arrosto, the Zuppa di Pesce and the Tortino di Melanzane all share well. The Stinco di Agnello, a braised lamb shank on saffron risotto, is the one to get for a risotto lover, and it reflects Chef Meliano Plascensia, who has cooked for more than 40 years and loves rice dishes above almost anything.
Finish with a few desserts down the middle. Tiramisu, Panna Cotta and the Tortino di Cioccolato go fastest.
If someone at the table asks where all this comes from, the Emilia-Romagna tourism board has a good primer on Bologna and Modena, home of ragù and tigelle.
Does Da Andrea Greenwich Village Have a Private Room for Groups?
No. Da Andrea Greenwich Village doesn’t have a private or semi-private dining room, and the restaurant’s own large-group page says so plainly. Every party, from four to thirty, dines in the main room alongside the regulars.
That’s a real trade-off, and we’d rather you know it now.
The West 13th Street room is intimate and beloved by regulars. A group fits best when the occasion is about eating and talking together, like a birthday or a team dinner after a long quarter. It suits a toast. It doesn’t suit a slideshow or a microphone.
Keep any speech to one short toast between courses, and seat the guest of honor in the middle of the long side so everyone can reach them. If your event truly needs a closed door, book a venue that has one.
A Group Dinner Built Around Union Square, NYU and Washington Square Park
The location is the other half of the group case: 35 West 13th Street sits between two of downtown’s busiest meeting points, so guests coming from different directions converge easily. That matters more for twelve people than for two.
Union Square is a few blocks northeast, with several subway lines underneath it. Office teams around the square can walk west to dinner, and out-of-towners can meet on the south side of the square and walk over together, so nobody trickles in late.
Head down Fifth Avenue instead and you reach the arch at Washington Square Park and the heart of the NYU campus. That makes this block a natural fit for Family Weekend and graduation season, when whole families want a sit-down meal near campus. Book those weeks early.
The Weekend Brunch Option
Weekend brunch on Saturdays and Sundays is the underrated group format here. Relatives are easier to gather the morning after a campus event, and the flatbreads and Salmone Affumicato on tigelle go around a table as easily as dinner antipasti.
There’s history on this block too. Da Andrea started in the early ’90s as a narrow storefront on Hudson Street serving Bolognese pastas, and the Greenwich Village dining room is the one that carries that original story. Sam Sifton reviewed it for the New York Times in 2002.
For more on the neighborhood itself, our earlier post on finding an Italian restaurant near Union Square covers the walk from the square.
Logistics That Keep a Large Party Running Smoothly
Most group dinners fail on logistics, not food. These are the steps worth doing, roughly in order.
- Book early, then confirm. For anything over twelve, reserve weeks ahead, and for NYU Family Weekend or graduation season, earlier than that.
- Name one point of contact. One person talks to the restaurant and handles the headcount and the card or deposit.
- Pre-agree the shared plates. Send the group a short list a few days before.
- Collect dietary needs in advance. Vegetarian guests are well covered. For allergies, tell the team when you book and remind your server on the night; don’t assume any dish is gluten-free.
- Arrive together. A table that sits down at once gets its first course at once.
- Settle the bill plan before dinner. Decide among yourselves how you’ll divide it, and ask about payment options when you book rather than at the end of the night.
For 20 or more, look at the Event Brochure on the large-group page. Its event prix-fixe menus and beverage packages take most of these decisions off your plate.
Plan Your Group Dinner at the Best Italian Restaurant for Groups Greenwich Village Has to Offer
If you’re weighing the best Italian restaurant for groups Greenwich Village has for your next birthday, family visit or team night, judge it by the host’s tests: sharing food, clear booking rules and an honest room. Da Andrea Greenwich Village passes on all three, as long as your event fits a lively main room rather than a private one.
Pick your shared plates from the Greenwich Village dinner menu, send parties over 12 to the large group events page, then reserve your table on West 13th Street.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I bring my own birthday cake to Da Andrea Greenwich Village?
Ask when you book rather than arriving with one. The simpler route is to order a few house desserts for the table, like Tiramisu and Panna Cotta, and let the birthday guest choose first.
How far ahead should I book a group dinner in Greenwich Village?
For six or fewer, a week or so is usually enough outside peak dates. For 13 or more, or any booking during NYU Family Weekend, graduation season or the December holidays, reserve several weeks out. Larger parties need the card hold or deposit in place before the booking is final.
Can children join a large family group?
Yes, a family group can include children. Plain dishes like Spaghetti Bolognese, the veal meatballs and the roasted potatoes tend to suit younger eaters, and family style lets kids take small portions of several things. If you need a high chair or booster seat, ask when you book.
What happens if some guests cancel at the last minute?
Tell the restaurant as soon as your headcount drops. For groups of 26 to 30, the 25% deposit is non-refundable, so only commit to that bracket once your numbers are firm. For smaller groups held by credit card, ask about the cancellation terms when you book.
Is the Greenwich Village menu different from the Chelsea one for groups?
Mostly the menus overlap, but the Calamaretti alla Griglia is listed only at Greenwich Village, while Chelsea has its own Fritto Misto and a weekday prix-fixe lunch. Greenwich Village doesn’t list a lunch menu online, so plan a Village group for dinner or weekend brunch.
Can a group order takeout for a gathering at home instead?
Yes. Pickup is available through the ordering page, and delivery runs through Grubhub, UberEats and DoorDash. For a home gathering, handmade pastas and the meatballs travel better than crisp dishes like grilled squid, which are best eaten at the table.
