An upscale Italian restaurant in Greenwich Village should give you pasta made by hand that day, a dinner that moves in courses, and a room where you can actually talk. That’s our position, and it’s why we’d point a parent in town for NYU, or anyone marking a promotion, to a kitchen before a captain in a tuxedo. At Da Andrea Greenwich Village, 35 West 13th Street between 5th and 6th Avenues, the fresh pasta is made in-house every day and the cooking comes from Bologna and Emilia-Romagna.
The lists that rank for this search mostly sort restaurants by ceremony and price tier. They rarely say what the extra effort should buy you at the table.
This guide does. It covers what “upscale” should mean on a Village block, how to order a full Northern Italian dinner, which table to book for which occasion, and the honest trade-offs of choosing a family-run ristorante over a formal dining room.
Key Takeaways
- An upscale Italian dinner is worth it when the money goes into the cooking: pasta made by hand daily, slow ragù, risotto stirred to order.
- Da Andrea Greenwich Village sits on West 13th Street, a few minutes’ walk from both Washington Square Park and Union Square.
- Order the Northern Italian way, in courses: antipasti to share, a pasta, then a secondo for those who want one.
- The room is intimate and neighborly rather than formal, so book ahead on weekends and plan a group of 10 or more early.
What Should an Upscale Italian Restaurant in Greenwich Village Give You?
It should give you food that took real hours to make and a table where nobody rushes you. Everything else is decoration.
Most “upscale” rankings measure what you can see from the door: banquettes, tablecloths, a sommelier’s cart. Those things cost money, and the diner pays for them. What they don’t tell you is whether the pappardelle was rolled that morning or arrived in a box.
We think the Village has always judged restaurants the other way round. Da Andrea started in the early ’90s as a narrow storefront on Hudson Street serving Bolognese pastas, and it became a Village favorite for more than two decades on the strength of what came out of the kitchen. The move to West 13th Street kept that habit.
Here’s how the usual markers of an upscale dinner compare with what we’d ask for instead.
| What lists call “upscale” | What it really buys you | What to look for at Da Andrea Greenwich Village |
|---|---|---|
| Formal service, a captain at every table | Polish and choreography | Someone who knows how the dishes are made and can steer your order |
| White tablecloths and a grand room | A sense of occasion | An intimate dining room full of regulars, where conversation carries |
| A long tasting menu | Many small plates in a fixed order | Courses you choose: antipasti, a primo, a secondo, dolce |
| Luxury ingredients on every plate | Truffle and lobster as signals | Truffle and lobster where they belong, in Cappellacci Tartufo e Porcini and Ravioli di Crostacei |
| A famous wine cellar | Bragging rights | A curated Italian list, with pairings matched to Bolognese cooking |
If your idea of a polished night is the left column, a family-run trattoria won’t feel right. If it’s the right column, keep reading.
The Kitchen Case: Pasta Made by Hand Every Day
Handmade pasta is the clearest sign that a kitchen is spending its effort where you can taste it. Fresh egg pasta has a soft, springy bite and grips a sauce in a way dried pasta can’t, and making it daily is slow, skilled work that no décor budget replaces.
The Greenwich Village menu reads like a map of northern Italy. Spaghetti Bolognese carries the slow meat sauce Bologna is known for. The Pappardelle comes with a sweet sausage ragout finished with truffle oil, and the Tagliolini Neri alle Vongole pairs squid ink pasta with clams, cherry tomatoes, garlic and white wine.
Stuffed pasta is where the craft shows most. Cappellacci Tartufo e Porcini are spinach ravioli filled with truffle mushroom and ricotta. Ravioli di Crostacei holds lobster, crab and salmon in a saffron sauce, and it’s the plate we’d order if the dinner needs one luxurious moment.
Then there’s the risotto. Chef Meliano Plascensia has more than 40 years in kitchens, and rice dishes like risotto are the ones he loves most. That’s why we’d point you at the Risotto del Giorno, which changes daily, or the Stinco di Agnello, a braised lamb shank served on saffron risotto.
If you want to read about the region these dishes come from, Emilia-Romagna’s official tourism site covers Bologna, Modena and the food traditions behind tigelle, ragù and filled pasta.
How to Order a Multi-Course Dinner on West 13th Street
Order the way a Bolognese family would on a Sunday: share small plates, give everyone a pasta, and decide on secondi only once you’ve seen how hungry the table is. This pacing is what turns a good meal into an occasion, and it costs nothing extra.
Here’s a full dinner built from the current Greenwich Village menu.
| Course | Greenwich Village pick | Why it works for a special dinner |
|---|---|---|
| To share | Tigelle Modenesi con Prosciutto | Warm Modenese flatbread buns with Parma prosciutto, made to be passed around |
| Antipasto | Calamaretti alla Griglia | Grilled squid with corn, cucumber and lemon; only on the Village menu |
| Antipasto (richer) | Carpaccio di Manzo or Burrata con Basilico | A cool, clean opening before heavier courses |
| Primo | Ravioli di Crostacei or Pappardelle | The handmade pasta is the reason to come, so don’t skip this course |
| Secondo | Filetto di Manzo with truffle butter, or Stinco di Agnello | The two most celebratory plates on the menu |
| Lighter secondo | Filetto di Salmone or Gamberoni | Grilled fish and jumbo shrimp for guests who want to finish lighter |
| Dolce | Panna Cotta with Amarene cherries, or Tiramisu | Classic endings; Affogato if someone wants coffee and dessert in one |
A few habits make the night go smoother.
Share the tigelle. They were featured in the New York Times “$25 and Under” column, and it’s a nice irony that the dish a budget column found is the right first move at a big-night dinner.
For a table of four, two antipasti, four pastas and two secondi split down the middle is plenty. Ask your server to pace the courses so the pasta lands as its own course rather than alongside the mains. And ask for a wine pairing from the Italian list once the pastas are chosen, since a ragù and a saffron ravioli want different glasses.
Our older post on dinner in Greenwich Village, course by course walks through each part of the menu in more detail.
Which Special Occasion Fits a Village Trattoria?
Most of them do, as long as the occasion is about the people at the table rather than the room around them. Here’s how we’d plan the dinners Village locals most often book.
| Occasion | What to book and order | Tip |
|---|---|---|
| Parents in town for NYU | A weekend table for the family; tigelle, Spaghetti Bolognese, Stinco di Agnello | Walk them up 5th Avenue from Washington Square Arch first |
| A promotion or new job | A table for two; Ravioli di Crostacei and Filetto di Manzo | Toast with a signature cocktail before ordering |
| A client dinner | A quieter table, booked well ahead; Carpaccio di Manzo, a pasta each | Keep confidential talk for the walk afterwards; the room is intimate |
| An anniversary | Two antipasti to share, then Cappellacci Tartufo e Porcini | Finish with Panna Cotta and an espresso |
| A group of 10 friends | Book early; family-style antipasti and a mix of pastas | Groups dine in the main room, with no separate space |
| Weekend celebration with family | Saturday or Sunday brunch | Benedict Aragosta (lobster) is the most festive plate on the brunch menu |
The NYU parent dinner is the one this block suits most naturally. You’ve spent the afternoon on campus, the student wants real food, and the parents want somewhere that feels like an event without being stiff.
West 13th Street gives you both.
A Village Evening Around 35 West 13th Street
Da Andrea Greenwich Village is on the quiet stretch of West 13th Street between 5th and 6th Avenues, close enough to the big Village landmarks to build an evening around them. That location is half the case for eating here rather than somewhere in Midtown.
Fifth Avenue runs south from the corner of 13th Street straight down to the arch at Washington Square Park, the heart of the NYU campus. A short walk down and back before dinner gives visiting families a look at the fountain, the arch and the buildings their student talks about, and you arrive at the table with an appetite.
Head the other way and Union Square Park is a few blocks to the northeast. It’s an easy meeting point for guests coming from different directions, with subway lines meeting underneath it, and the walk west on 13th Street takes you off the busy corners onto a calmer residential block.
That shift in pace matters more than any chandelier.
Between the two parks, the side streets of the Village are made for wandering after dessert. Our own story runs through these streets too, from the first storefront on Hudson Street to the dining room on 13th, and many of the people at the next table have been coming for years. Sam Sifton reviewed Da Andrea for the New York Times in 2002.
The Trade-Offs of Choosing a Family-Run Ristorante
The honest trade-off is this: you give up formality and gain cooking, warmth and a fair chance of being remembered next time. For most special dinners we think that’s the right swap, though not for every one.
It’s cozy, not grand. The Greenwich Village dining room is intimate and neighborly. If the evening needs hushed, spaced-out tables for a deal you can’t be overheard discussing, a formal hotel dining room suits that brief better.
Book ahead, especially on weekends. An intimate room fills quickly. Reserve through OpenTable from the reservation page, and give us as much notice as you can for Friday and Saturday dinners or weekend brunch.
Groups have clear rules. Parties of up to 25 guests hold a booking with a credit card, and groups of 26 to 30 need a deposit. There’s no private dining room, so a large party shares the main room with everyone else, which suits a lively birthday more than a speech-heavy event.
The menu changes in places. The risotto, the soup and the daily specials rotate, so a dish you loved last visit may not be there. Ask what’s new before you order.
Dietary needs. Several pasta and vegetable dishes are vegetarian, such as Fettuccine alla Mediterranea and Pennette con Melanzane. For an allergy, tell your server before ordering so the kitchen can advise.
Book Your Upscale Italian Restaurant Greenwich Village Dinner on West 13th Street
If you want an upscale Italian restaurant in Greenwich Village where the effort shows up on the plate, book a table on West 13th Street and order in courses. Start with the tigelle, give the pasta its own course, and leave room for panna cotta.
Get directions on the Greenwich Village location page, then reserve your table through OpenTable.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Da Andrea Greenwich Village good for a business dinner?
It works well for a relationship dinner where the goal is good food and easy conversation. The room is intimate, so we’d suggest booking ahead, asking for a quieter table, and keeping truly confidential points for the walk afterwards. Order a few antipasti for the table so nobody has to commit right away.
Can I order a pasta as a starter, Italian style?
Yes, ordering a pasta as the primo before a secondo is the traditional Italian way to eat, and it’s how we’d suggest planning a celebration dinner. Sharing one or two pastas across the table leaves room for the Filetto di Manzo or Stinco di Agnello afterwards.
What makes Northern Italian cooking different from the red-sauce menus many New Yorkers grew up with?
Northern Italian cooking, especially from Bologna and Emilia-Romagna, leans on fresh egg pasta, stuffed pasta, slow meat ragù, butter, risotto and cured meats like Parma prosciutto. You’ll see that on the Greenwich Village menu in the Spaghetti Bolognese, the Cappellacci, the tigelle and the saffron risotto under the lamb shank.
Is there anything on the Greenwich Village menu I can’t get at the Chelsea location?
Yes. The Calamaretti alla Griglia, grilled squid with a corn and cucumber salad and lemon dressing, is listed only on the Greenwich Village menu. The two locations share most dinner dishes, but it’s worth checking each location’s menu page before you go.
Can I celebrate a birthday at Da Andrea Greenwich Village?
Yes. Mention the occasion when you book so the team knows, and plan the size of your party early. Groups of up to 25 hold a booking with a credit card and groups of 26 to 30 need a deposit; everyone dines in the main room.
Does Da Andrea Greenwich Village serve brunch for a weekend celebration?
Yes, brunch runs on Saturdays and Sundays. For a festive late morning, the Benedict Aragosta with lobster, the Salmone Affumicato on fresh tigelle and the Chitarra alla Carbonara make a brunch feel like an occasion.
